Hurricane Screens vs. Hurricane Shutters: Which Is Right for Palm Beach Homes?

If you own a home in Jupiter, Palm Beach Gardens, West Palm Beach, Wellington or anywhere along the Treasure Coast, you have probably asked the same question: should I put up hurricane screens or hurricane shutters? Both are designed to protect your windows and doors from wind and flying debris. They go about it differently, and the right choice depends on your home, your daily habits and what you want it to look like when the sky is clear.

This guide walks through how each option works, where each one shines, and the questions to ask before you decide.

What Are Hurricane Shutters?

Hurricane shutters are solid or louvered barriers that cover an opening during a storm. There are several styles, and each suits a different kind of home.

  • Accordion shutters slide horizontally on tracks and lock closed over a window or a series of windows. They are easy to operate, they are one of the more budget-friendly options, and they work well on curved windows and unusual shapes. See our accordion shutters page for details.

  • Rolling shutters store in a compact housing above the opening and roll down when needed. The Nautilus Rolling Shutter, which we manufacture and install, can be operated by electric motor, crank or hand. Learn more on our Nautilus rolling shutters page.

  • Bahama and colonial shutters mount on the outside of the home and double as decorative exterior shutters. Bahama shutters prop open like an awning to shade the window, while colonial shutters fold against the sides of the window.

Solid shutters give you a barrier you can count on, and many also add a layer of security when closed.

What Are Hurricane Screens?

Hurricane screens are a strong, woven fabric panel held in aluminum tracks and housings. Instead of blocking the opening, the screen is a barrier that still lets you see through it. At Expert Shutter Services, we make Ultrashield hurricane screens right here in Port St. Lucie, using a fabric developed in collaboration with Twitchell, one of the largest screen manufacturers in the world.

Our system uses end retention, a method that pulls the fabric tight from all four sides, so the screen stays flat instead of sagging. You can see the full list of features on our hurricane screens page.

Hurricane Screens vs. Hurricane Shutters: Key Differences

Light and visibility

This is the biggest everyday difference. A solid shutter blocks light when it is closed, so a house can feel like a cave during a long storm. A hurricane screen lets natural light in and lets you see what is happening outside. If you spend storm days at home with kids, pets or a nervous family member, that can matter more than you expect.

Appearance

Rolling shutters tuck into small housings, and screens come in multiple colors for both the fabric and the aluminum parts. Bahama and colonial shutters are visible all year, so they become part of your home's style. Accordion shutters stay at the sides of the openings when they are not in use. Think about how each option looks from the street, especially if you live in a community with architectural guidelines.

Everyday benefits

Beyond storm season, screens also act as a bug screen and cut down on sun exposure. Their dense fabric can reduce solar heat gain, which helps rooms stay cooler. Solid shutters bring year-round security and shade, and rolling shutters can help block sunlight when they are lowered.

Operation

Accordion shutters are simple and manual, so you slide them and lock them. Rolling shutters and screens can be motorized, with remote control, and our Ultrashield screens can even be set up for operation through a phone app. If you have large openings, a lanai or a hard-to-reach window, motorized operation can make storm prep much faster.

Budget

Accordion shutters are among the more affordable ways to protect a home. Motorized systems and custom screens usually cost more up front. Because every home is different, the only way to know your cost is to get a measured quote.

Which Is Right for Your Palm Beach Area Home?

Here are a few common situations and the options homeowners often consider.

  • Large lanai or patio openings: Screens and rolling systems are popular here because motorized operation saves time and you keep your view.

  • Curved or odd-shaped windows: Accordion shutters are one of the few choices that handle curves and protrusions.

  • Tight budget: Accordion shutters are typically the most budget-friendly place to start.

  • Want screens and shutters together: The Nautilus Roll/Screen Combination puts a rolling shutter and an Ultrashield insect or solar screen in one compact housing. Check out the Nautilus combo system to see how it works.

  • Security matters to you: A closed solid shutter is a deterrent to break-ins as well as storms.

Many homes mix products, with screens on the lanai and solid shutters on bedroom windows, for example. You do not have to pick one style for the whole house.

Questions to Ask Before You Choose

Before you sign anything, ask each contractor:

  • Does this specific product have a current product approval, and can I see the paperwork?

  • Who manufactures it, and who installs it?

  • What will the permit and inspection process involve in my city?

  • How is the system operated, and what happens if the power goes out?

  • How should it be maintained, and who can repair it later?

Requirements vary by location and by home, so use your local building department and your insurance provider as the final word. Our FAQs cover some of the most common questions, including permits and insurance.

Get a Measured Recommendation

The best way to compare hurricane screens and hurricane shutters is to look at your actual windows, doors and lanai with someone who installs both. Expert Shutter Services has served Treasure Coast homes and businesses, including Stuart homeowners, since 1988 and also serves Jupiter, Palm Beach Gardens, West Palm Beach, Wellington and nearby communities. Call us at 772-871-1915 or contact us online to talk through your options.

Previous
Previous

How to Prepare Your Home Before Hurricane Season: A Palm Beach Checklist

Next
Next

Ultimate Storm Defense for Florida Homeowners